The judge at the county fair in Modesto told me my sourdough was overproofed and I almost argued with her
I brought two loaves to the Stanislaus County fair back in July and figured I had it in the bag after placing second a year before. The judge cut into my bread, looked at the crumb for maybe 5 seconds, and told me it was overproofed and the gluten had gone slack. I wanted to tell her she was wrong but she pointed at the flat spots near the bottom crust and I shut up real quick. Turns out I had been letting my bulk go an extra 45 minutes because my kitchen runs cold and I never adjusted for it. Now I poke the dough every 20 minutes past the 3 hour mark and pull it as soon as it springs back slow. My loaves have been way more consistent since then and I actually got a blue ribbon at the next show. How do you all judge proofing when your house temp swings 10 degrees between seasons?
Reminds me of my uncle who swore by the "looks about right" method until his kitchen got drafty one winter and every loaf came out like a brick. Now he tapes a cheap thermometer to the counter and checks it like a hawk.