OEM vs aftermarket fenders on a 2014 Civic, what's your call?

Got a 2014 Civic in the shop last week, rear quarter was bent bad and the customer wanted a used aftermarket fender to save $180 over the OEM part. I went with OEM because the aftermarket one had a gap at the door line I couldn't live with, but now I'm second guessing if I overcharged the guy. Anyone else run into this and what side do you land on when the price difference is that close?

1 comments

1 Comment

dakotacraig16d ago

Hell no, the gap would've bugged me more than the $180 ever could.