Stuck with an AI-generated plot twist in my novel

I tried a new AI tool that helps writers come up with story ideas. For my mystery book, it suggested the villain is the main character's pet parrot. The AI says this is a fresh take based on data, but it just feels odd. I'm not sure if I should change the story or keep the weird twist. Has anyone run into AI giving strange advice for creative projects? I could use some tips on when to follow AI ideas and when to ignore them. Maybe there are other tools that handle this better.