Spent 4 hours trying to fix a blotchy stain on a walnut table
I was working on a walnut dining table last week and the stain came out looking like a patchwork quilt. Took me way too long to realize I forgot to use a pre-stain conditioner before applying the oil-based stain. Finally figured it out after sanding it back down twice, which cost me a whole Saturday afternoon. Has anyone else had that sinking feeling when you wipe on the stain and see it's all uneven?
The pre-stain conditioner would've saved you a lot of grief, but honestly even with it walnut can be a pain if the grain is really wild. I've had good luck using a gel stain instead on tricky pieces, it sits on top more instead of soaking in uneven.
Can totally relate to that sick feeling when you wipe on the stain and see it's all splotchy and uneven. Did the same thing on an oak nightstand a few months back, spent three hours sanding it down with 80 grit then 120, then 220, just to get back to bare wood. Ended up using a gel stain too, like the other commenter mentioned, and it actually came out really nice and even. Walnut is definitely a wild card with that open grain, and I've learned the hard way that skipping the conditioner is like asking for trouble. Makes you wonder why they don't just put a warning sticker on the can or something. Felt so dumb after finally getting it right on the third try.